Discerning elucidations regarding whatever comes to mind.

Why Human Climate Change Is A Fact 20 February, 2010

Filed under: Something Else — bonzairob @ 2:03 pm
Tags: ,

I doubt that many people will read this, but this is something I (or rather, my girlfriend) come across a lot. People who don’t believe in climate change tend not to understand it. SO I want to make a simple(ish) example.

Now I’m not saying everyone who knows it’s true understands it either; that’s why we have scientists who devote their lives to studying a field. If it were simple, we would already have flying cars. Hence simple(ish); it’s not a simple issue, or a simple process. Don’t let anyone tell you otherwise.

But the fact is, the people who comment on blogs and news sites saying it’s a myth are either A) dramatically uninformed or B) plants by oil companies. You might think B sounds paranoid or cynical, but it’s not. They target older men, making it seem like scientists are trying to fool them, and younger women, to get them before they become eco-friendly hippies.

So enough about misinformation; why is climate change a fact?

It’s all about the coral reefs.

My father spends his life variously studying marine animals, selling products relating to marine animals, writing articles about marine animals, feeding marine animals, and laughing at marine animals when they do stupid things. I grew up around this, and absorbed a lot of information in a tangential sort of way. Even though I don’t keep a marine tank, I probably know more than people who do (which is a separate issue that my dad’s doing his best to address).

Everyone knows what a coral reef is. But, did you know that it’s corals themselves that make the rock that reefs are built on?
Like us, they have a calcium skeleton. On top of this is their flesh, and then their polyps, which are a combination mouth and bum, surrounded by (usually stinging) tentacles.

Inside their skin, living about two million to the square inch, are tiny algae. The algae acts like any plant and gives the coral energy from sunlight; the coral eats whatever swims into its tentacles and the algae gets a bit to act as fertiliser. It’s probably the most mutually-beneficial system in the entirety of nature.

Corals’ flesh is made out of their equivalent of stem cells. They can regrow anything that gets damaged and don’t have a lifespan! There are polyps that could easily be thousands of years old, and I don’t mean the species, I mean a single coral.

So how is this related to climate change?

There are two main ways. There are also hundreds of thousands of indirect ways, but I’m trying to keep this information clear.

The first way is “bleaching”. You may have heard, in the record-breaking summers of 1997 and 1998, a sixth of the world’s reefs bleached. There have been a few sumemrs since then where a similar thing happened. This should be absolutely terrifying, and was to anyone involved with marine biology in any way, but most people don’t understand the significance because of the wording.

Bleaching, for all intents and purposes, means dying.

When a coral is said to have bleached, it means the algae in its skin has left the coral and swum away. (Their latin name is dinoflagellates, which means whirling whip, which is how they swim.) This leaves the coral white, hence bleaching, but it also leaves it without most of its energy, without any protection against UV light, and in conditions that were bad enough to make the algae leave to start with. They’ll live for a little while after, and if conditions improve they algae might come back, but over a summer that lasts for a few months, the majority of the bleached coral died.

The second way is more directly to do with carbon dioxide in the atmosphere.

A lot of people hold that the rising carbon in the atmosphere is part of a cycle. This is utter, complete bollocks, and no-one should believe this. Remember how I said there are single polyps that are thousands of years old? There wouldn’t be, if this were a cycle. Carbon dioxide kills coral.

A huge amount of carbon dioxide is absorbed into sea-water, and it’s nearing saturation, so not much more is going to be absorbed.
Carbon Dioxide is an acidic gas, and it makes sea-water more acidic too. Calcium, which corals’ bones are made of, is alkaline.

You know the diet coke and mentoes thing, where the alkaline mints fizz up and dissolve in acidic coke?

Imagine that happening to your bones. Slowly, constantly, painfully.

THAT is how carbon dioxide kills coral. And that is why it is not a natural cycle, because if it was, all our coral reefs would date back to the last time CO2 peaked. They don’t; huge structures like the Great Barrier Reef were formed over MILLIONS of years. If there is any cycle at all, we have horrendously kicked it into overdrive.

So what’s going to happen to the reefs?

Basically, unless we dramatically cut back on carbon emissions and all that jazz RIGHT NOW, they’re dead.

All of them.

The rainforest of the sea, with two-thirds of the ocean’s animals (by species, more by numbers) and therefore half of the entire planet’s life, will be dead and gone within twenty years. A lot of people have just given up hope and, like my dad, are concentrating on keeping them in tanks, so we can preserve a tiny bit of that life.

That’s why climate change, caused by humans, is a fact. And that is why I loathe it when people say “it’s not real” or “it’s a cycle”. And why you should too.

Sources: The QI Book of Animal Ignorance, my life and childhood, the sites linked above.


6 Responses to “Why Human Climate Change Is A Fact”

  1. Dougetit Says:

    Since Phil Jones, the AGW advocate who is being investigated for fraud, has stated that Global Temperatures have not warmed in the past 15 years, is it possible that the coral reef may be affected by global cooling?


    • bonzairob Says:

      That’s an interesting article! But yes, there’s a reason I refrained from saying “global warming” in my post; the sheer complexity of climate science means there’s warming and cooling and all sorts of unusual weather happening. Global warming is a misnomer to be avoided.

      • Dougetit Says:

        Thanks for your reply…

        Is there anything to this link?


      • bonzairob Says:

        No, there isn’t. This says it all:

        Zoologists at the University of British Columbia (UBC) researched the impact of ocean acidification on marine invertebrates that don’t have a large calcified skeleton or external shell. What they have found debunks the global warmist doomsayers’ guesstimates about the potential impact of climate change on marine species.

        Emphasis mine. They’ve cherry-picked a study that has nothing to do with what my post was about, coral reefs, adn claimed that is means nothing bad will happen to oceanic life. It doesn’t debunk anything about man-made climate change, since no-one’s claiming that all life will be wiped out by it (for a long time, anyway).

        Life will probably go on in the ocean whatever happens, and there may even be some form of reef. Even if all life on land dies in a nuclear holocaust, which is why that fact isn’t comforting. Even so, it will be unimaginably different life to what’s there now. And of course, there will be unpredictable ramifications in every direction. There’s no simple solution to anything here, but denying the problem only exacerbates it.

  2. Dougetit Says:

    Thanks… I thought so…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s